Is Pakistan REALLY a Failed State? | Anatol Lieven's "Pakistan: A Hard Country" Honest Review скачать в хорошем качестве

Is Pakistan REALLY a Failed State? | Anatol Lieven's "Pakistan: A Hard Country" Honest Review

Is Pakistan a failing state or a resilient society? In this video, we dive deep into Anatol Lieven's groundbreaking book, "Pakistan: A Hard Country," to understand the complex reality of Pakistan beyond the headlines. This isn't your typical political analysis. Based on years of firsthand research and on-the-ground reporting, Lieven breaks down why Pakistan's powerful institutions, deep-rooted social structures, and incredible people make it a "hard" country to break, despite its many challenges. In this book review, we cover: 0:00 Introduction 0:06 How Pakistan Compares to India, Bangladesh & Afghanistan 0:37 The Paradox of Benazir Bhutto's Leadership & Women's Rights 1:57 The Deep-Rooted Feudal System (Vaderas, Wadairas) 2:09 The Cycle of Democracy & Dictatorship 2:28 Was Jinnah Secular? The Debate on Pakistan's Foundation 2:37 Land, People, and History of Pakistan 3:21 Analysis of State Structures: Justice, Police, & Judiciary 4:04 Why the Police is Under-Resourced 4:52 The Role of the Military & Its Business Empire 5:56 The Military's Structure & Power - The Most Organized Institution? 6:43 Religion's Role: The Rise of Deobandism & Foreign Influence (Saudi/Iran) 7:49 Politics: The Root of All Problems? 8:13 Analysis of Provinces: Punjab's Dominance, Sindh's Feudalism, KP's Tribal Culture 9:55 The Balochistan Question 10:28 The Pashtun Culture & FCR (Frontier Crimes Regulation) 11:20 Understanding the Taliban's Rise & Motivations 11:53 Final Verdict: Who Should Read This Book? Whether you're a student of political science, international relations, or just curious about Pakistan, this book offers a nuanced perspective you won't find in the news. Don't forget to: 👍 LIKE if you found this review insightful! 💬 COMMENT below - Do you agree with Lieven's analysis? Is Pakistan a "Hard Country"? 🔔 SUBSCRIBE for more deep dives into books on geopolitics and history! 📤 SHARE with anyone interested in South Asian politics! BOOKS MENTIONED: "Pakistan: A Hard Country" by Anatol Lieven CHAPTER TIMESTAMPS: 0:00 - Intro 0:06 - Pakistan's Global Comparison 0:37 - Society & Women's Rights 2:09 - Democracy vs. Dictatorship 2:28 - Jinnah's Vision Debate 2:37 - History & People 3:21 - State Structures (Police, Judiciary) 4:52 - The Military's Power 6:43 - Role of Religion 7:49 - Political Analysis 8:13 - Provincial Breakdown (Punjab, Sindh, KP, Balochistan) 11:20 - Understanding the Taliban 11:53 - Final Thoughts #Pakistan #AnatolLieven #BookReview #Geopolitics #InternationalRelations #PoliticalScience #PakistaniYoutuber #SouthAsia #PakistanStudies #NonFiction #HardCountry #PakMilitary #Jinnah #Taliban #Feudalism #Punjab #Sindh #Balochistan #Pashtun #Debate #CurrentAffairs #UPSC #CSS #IAS #Pakistan #BookReview #Geopolitics #PoliticalScience #CSS #UPSC #InternationalRelations #LearnWithYouTube #PakistaniYoutuber #MustRead #Explained