Can Non-Jews Do Mitzvos—and Does It Count? | Noahide Laws, Rambam vs. Rav Moshe, Shabbos & More скачать в хорошем качестве

Can Non-Jews Do Mitzvos—and Does It Count? | Noahide Laws, Rambam vs. Rav Moshe, Shabbos & More

Do non-Jews (Bnei Noach) receive reward for mitzvos? This shiur unpacks classic sources on voluntary mitzvah performance: women and time-bound mitzvos (gadol ha-metzuvah ve’oseh), ethical “mitzvos sichliyos,” korbanos from non-Jews, learning the Seven Noahide Laws, and why formal Shabbos observance is prohibited. We compare Rambam’s seemingly expansive view (with intent caveats) to Rav Moshe Feinstein’s stricter approach, plus practical guidance on tefillin, mezuzah, lulav/sukkah, and matzah. Sources discussed: Yerushalmi, Sanhedrin, Chullin, Trumas 3; Midrash Rabbah (Koheles); Rambam (Hil. Milah; Peirush ha-Mishnayos; Teshuvos); Radvaz; Igros Moshe. Takeaway: Strong yes for ethics/chesed and learning one’s obligations; clear no on “keeping Shabbos”; gray area (with cautions) on covenantal symbols. #Noahide #Mitzvos #JewishLaw #Rambam #Halacha #BneiNoach #Shabbos #Tefillin #Mezuzah #Chessed Noahide laws, Bnei Noach, non-Jews mitzvot, mitzvos for gentiles, gadol ha-metzuvah ve’oseh, women time-bound mitzvot, mitzvos sichliyos, ethical commandments, Rambam, Maimonides, Radvaz, Rav Moshe Feinstein, Igros Moshe, Yerushalmi, Sanhedrin, Chullin, Trumas, Midrash Rabbah Koheles, korbanot by non-Jews, learning Torah for non-Jews, Shabbos for non-Jews, tefillin for non-Jews, mezuzah for non-Jews, lulav and sukkah, matzah, halacha shiur, Jewish thought, Torah class