My journal paper was rejected. Should I resubmit to the same journal or try another? скачать в хорошем качестве

My journal paper was rejected. Should I resubmit to the same journal or try another?

I’ve been rejected by one journal. Should I resubmit to the same journal or try another? Here is what to do if your research paper is rejected by a journal. Watch all of our videos on submitting your journal paper: https://bit.ly/3pNnCei =====CHAPTERS===== 0:00 Intro on how to resubmit a journal 0:18 No chance of publication in that journal 1:12 Typical journal responses to a paper submission 3:03 Can a paper rejection decision be changed? 3:16 Two types of issues: editorial and technical 6:00 Life sciences criteria 6:24 Social sciences criteria 6:58 Determine your new target journal =====SCRIPT OF VIDEO===== Typical journal responses to a paper submission review come in five forms: Accept: This means the journal publishes your paper in its current state. Accept with minor revisions: The journal is willing to publish your paper given you or the co-authors make minor corrections as suggested by the reviewers or handling editor. Accept with major revisions: The journal is willing to publish your paper given you or the co-authors make major corrections as suggested by the reviewers and/or the handling editor. Revise and resubmit: This means that the journal rejects your paper in its current state but is willing to consider publishing it following major revisions and a new peer review cycle. Reject: The journal will not publish your paper in its current state or any alternative or modified states. If rejected, your only option is to submit to another journal. Can a reject decision be changed? Only in extenuating circumstances can authors contest a paper rejection. There are two types of issues: editorial and technical. Let's look at the different kinds of issues that you might see in a Journal response letter. Each kind of issue requires a different action by the author. Some issues don't prevent you from resubmitting to the same journal; other issues do mean that you need to find a new target journal. Lack of adherence to journal formatting requirements: This issue can be fixed by language editors, and the paper can be resubmitted to the same journal. Lack of clarity, quality, or detail in language and data presentation: This issue can be fixed by language editors. If the issue is insufficient up-to-date references, the authors can add and update the references, and the paper can be resubmitted to the same journal. If the editorial issue is insufficient impact or value for the journal (the journal does not feel this paper is a good fit), you should consider submitting to another journal. If the issue is that it is out of scope for the journal, the paper could be submitted to another journal as it could be within the scope of another journal. Weak, unclear, or scientifically invalid research objectives or hypotheses: This issue can be fixed by the authors by strengthening and revising the objectives or hypotheses. Editors can clarify the language, and the paper can be resubmitted to the same journal, depending on the review decision. Practical example for Life Sciences: Most journals within the life sciences employ the same paper accepted criteria previously discussed in this video. In the notes of the video, there will be a useful link to a SlideShare presentation on how to write a scientific paper and get it published. Practical example for social sciences: Journals within the social sciences rely on the general criteria outlined previously in the video, with the exception of cases whereby you can demonstrate that the reviewers are subject to unfair bias or have misunderstood the research. Generally, however, it is ideal to pursue a new journal following rejection by submitting the next highest impact journal on your list of preferred publications for the research. Determine a new target journal if the reason for rejection is based on the unsuitability of your research or results for the journal. Determining the right journal to submit to is your priority. Reading past issues of one journal to acquire a sense of the aims, scope, level, length, and readership of the journal could help you determine if the journal is right for your research and thus enhance the probability of your research being accepted. Once again, this is Emily from uni-edit. Thanks for watching and have a wonderful day. =====PLAYLISTS===== Resubmitting your journal paper after rejection https://bit.ly/3sRYvJi Journal paper rejected by a journal https://bit.ly/3mRrOIl Be successful at publishing in academic journals, getting accepted https://bit.ly/32CDms1 =====UNI-EDIT SERVICES FOR AUTHORS===== University English Editing & Translation service: https://uni-edit.net Uni-edit specializes in language services for academics and researchers. Research paper English editing: https://www.uni-edit.net/english-editing Thesis and dissertation editing: https://www.uni-edit.net/phd-masters Academic translation: https://www.uni-edit.net/translation Email: uniedit.global@gmail.com PUB042