Open challenge to Muslims ! Come and prove Allah is beyond time. скачать в хорошем качестве

Open challenge to Muslims ! Come and prove Allah is beyond time.

Is Allah really outside of time? Can a timeless God create a temporal universe without contradiction? In this video, I carefully examine and refute the classical Islamic claim that Allah exists beyond time while still creating and interacting with the world. Drawing from Ash'ari and Maturidi theology, I analyze the arguments about: Time being a created entity Allah’s “eternal attribute” of creation (Takwin) The concept of non-discursive divine knowledge The “timeless now” or block universe model The claim that only relationships change — not God Then I present a philosophical critique showing why these explanations create serious metaphysical tensions. Key Problems Addressed: Timeless Causation Problem If Allah’s will is eternal and unchanging, why is the universe not eternal? Eternal Cause, Delayed Effect Can an eternal act produce a temporal beginning without change? Divine Knowledge and Tensed Facts How can a timeless being know what is happening “now”? Prayer and Divine Response If Allah responds to prayer, does that imply change? Takwin and Immutability Can an eternal creative attribute produce non-eternal effects? Block Universe vs Free Will Does ET-simultaneity undermine real contingency? This is not an emotional argument. It is a metaphysical examination of coherence. If divine timelessness leads to contradiction, the doctrine requires serious reconsideration. Timestamps 00:00 Introduction 02:15 What Islamic Theology Claims About Time 05:30 The Problem of Timeless Causation 09:10 Eternal Will vs Temporal Creation 13:40 Divine Knowledge and Temporal Facts 17:20 Can Allah Truly Respond to Prayer? 21:00 The Block Universe Problem 24:00 Final Assessment Keywords (SEO) timeless Allah refuted is Allah outside time Islamic philosophy critique Ashari theology criticism Maturidi takwin explained divine timelessness problem eternal cause temporal effect does Allah change philosophy of religion debate block universe and God immutability of God criticism Islam metaphysics debate If you enjoy serious philosophy of religion debates, make sure to: Like the video Comment your response Subscribe for more structured refutations and philosophical analysis Let’s examine ideas critically and respectfully.