On Hakim's Nuance (And a challenge) скачать в хорошем качестве

On Hakim's Nuance (And a challenge)

Youtuber Hakim has become quite possibly the most popular Marxist-Leninist online. Unfortunately I've noticed over time that there is a pattern in his work which appears to consistently and intentionally obscure arguments and historical events that would seem to invalidate or cast strong doubt on his viewpoints. So today I decided to contest some of this by using the base of his 'What is a Tankie" video, coming from the perspective of a former 'Tankie'. Hakim's Video:    • What are tankies? (why are they like that?)   1. Tankie: The origins of an epithet https://hatfulofhistory.wordpress.com... 2. Introduction to Anti-Bolshevik Communism https://www.marxists.org/archive/matt... 3. Sugrue, The Latter Wittgenstein    • Great Minds - Part 5 - The Latter Wittgens...   3.1 The Getty Section (Forgot to put an annotation sorry) https://sovietinfo.tripod.com/GTY-Pen... 4. This is very rare painting by Mattias Koeppel called '...and everything will be fine again' satirising reunification. On display at the Leipzig Contemporary History Forum. https://www.hdg.de/lemo/bestand/objek... 5. Rojava: Reality vs Rhetoric from Organise Spring 2015 https://files.libcom.org/files/org84%... 6. We need to talk about 'Authoritarianism' by Second Thought    • We Need To Talk About "Authoritarianism"   7. Read 'On Authority' by JudgeSabo (probably the most in depth and thorough critique) https://theanarchistlibrary.org/libra... 8. What is Security Culture? https://sv.crimethinc.com/2004/11/01/... 9. Anarchist Direct Actions: A challenge to law enforcement: https://files.libcom.org/files/ADA%20... 10: Orwell was a terrible human being by Hakim    • George Orwell was a terrible human being   (FOR THE RECORD. I think I was a bit too lenient in my criticisms of Orwell. I would also conclude that he wasn't a very nice person even if he made some good points. But the point of Hakim's double standards with Orwell and Stalin still stand which is the main point I was trying to get across) 11: Stalin handed hundreds of Communists over to Hitler: https://jacobin.com/2021/08/hitler-st... (By the way I know that some are going to reference Grover Furr's refutation of this article, its terrible. Furr literally claims that because the comintern did not consider them communists, they weren't deporting communists. As if Communism is just a job description. Typical Furrism.) Some cool people: Call me Steve:   / stuheevun      / @stuheevun   Noj Rants:    / @nojrants   Abbey Heffer:   / ucecpsoj9qupxm99ympunyvw      / @authoritarianism101   Burn these Books:    / @burnthesebooks   00:00 - Intro 02:15 - Origin of the term 06:40 - Definitions of Tankie 14:00 - Marxist Leninist 'NUANCE' 26:30 - Eurocentrism and "Marxism Leninism is popular in the global south" 29:20 - Sexy vs Ugly Socialists 30:18 - 'Authoritarianism' 31:55 - Hakim's bad attack on Anarchism 38:54 - State formation and State power 41:15 - 'Excesses' 44:25 - Hakim recommends 'On Authority' (Challenge) 46:55 - Conclusion and a constructive critique of the Black Panther Party 54:20 - EPILOGUE (Orwell)