The Rabbis' Isnad Chain That Built Islam's Hadith "Science" (Talmudic Dilemma Part 16) скачать в хорошем качестве

The Rabbis' Isnad Chain That Built Islam's Hadith "Science" (Talmudic Dilemma Part 16)

The Early Tafsir are mostly based on Jewish understanding of the things found withing Islam. Sharia is based on Rabbinic Legal systems. And the Isnad 'science' seems to copy the oral authority of Rabbis for legal debates on the 'Book'. Why? This is a continuation of the Islamic Dilemma argument. It is another piece of the puzzle which both strengthens the Islamic Dilemma while also disproving Islam in a different way. They complement each other and both show that Islam has to be false. The Quran claims it is God’s direct, unique revelation given only through prophets (Surah 42:51; Surah 4:163–165), and Mohammad is presented as the final prophet (33:40) and there were no prophets between Isa and Mohammad (Sahih al-Bukhari 3442). Yet large, specific passages in the Quran closely parallel rabbinic Midrash and Talmudic material (Mishnah ~200 AD; Gemara 300–500 AD) that was circulating in late antiquity. That creates a dilemma: either God revealed truth through Jewish rabbis who were not prophets for centuries — which contradicts the Quran’s own doctrine — or Mohammad heard and incorporated human Jewish and Christian material and presented it as divine revelation. The simplest, historically coherent explanation is the latter: the Quran contains human-sourced material. Which undermines the claim that the Quran is wholly divine and inimitable. FULL TALMUDIC DILEMMA ARGUMENT HERE: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Y... SLIDES HERE: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iF_2... Music for Intro: The Sun Rises In The East by Tunc Alicioglu B Roll: https://www.storyblocks.com/ Join this channel to get access to perks:    / @defendingalion   Defending A Lion with Chris Harvey =========================== Check out my website here: https://defendingalion.com/ =========================== Social Links: ➡︎Twitter: https://x.com/DefendingALion ➡︎Facebook:   / 100090811616732   ➡︎TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@defendingalio... ➡︎Instagram:   / defendingalionministries   =========================== ⏰ Timestamps ⏰: 0:00 Intro 1:05 Isnad is a weak Method 1:50 Isnad is DEEPLY Rabbinic 2:50 Why the Rabbi's Isnad is more reliable 4:20 Muslims should trust the Rabbinic Isnad chain for the Mishnah 5:30 The Mishnah Dilemma #DefendingALion #christianity #god #bible #talmud #talmudicdilemma ⁠islam #quran #allah