‘Vande Mataram गाना देशभक्ति का certificate नहीं’ हमसे समझिए पीछे का खेल скачать в хорошем качестве

‘Vande Mataram गाना देशभक्ति का certificate नहीं’ हमसे समझिए पीछे का खेल

In this report for The Red Mike, Saurabh Shukla dissects the sudden revival of the "Vande Mataram" controversy. He argues that while the song is a historical symbol of patriotism, the government’s recent push for mandatory recital is a calculated move to fuel "counter-polarization." By enforcing a song that contains imagery conflicting with certain religious beliefs, Saurabh suggests the goal is to provoke a reaction from minority communities to consolidate a majority vote. Quick Context: • Mandatory Guidelines: New rules require Vande Mataram at presidential events, gubernatorial programs, and in all schools. • Constitutional Conflict: The debate pits state-mandated nationalist expression against Article 25, which guarantees religious freedom. • Historical Compromise: A 1937 committee (including Nehru and Bose) previously settled this by selecting only the non-controversial stanzas. • Political Diversion: Saurabh questions why this is a priority now, given the crises in farming, employment, and pollution. [00:00:00 - 00:03:15] The "Shagufa" of Polarization Saurabh opens by explaining how specific political narratives rely on minority reactions. He notes that Vande Mataram was never an issue in his school days, where students of all faiths sang it together. The problem, he argues, isn't the song, but the "patriotism certificate" the government is now attaching to it. Saurabh Shukla: "वंदे मातरम को लेकर के देश में कोई विवाद नहीं था... लेकिन अगर आप यह कह दें कि यह नियम बना दिया गया और आपको गाना ही गाना है वरना कारवाई होगी तो थोड़ा मुश्किल हो जाती है।" He also highlights the sharp rhetoric from the UP Chief Minister regarding those who hesitate to sing. Yogi Adityanath: "जो कह रहा है कि वंदे मातरम नहीं गाएगा उसे देश में रहने की आजादी नहीं होनी चाहिए उसको देश छोड़ देना चाहिए।" [00:03:16 - 00:07:45] Historical Compromise vs. Modern Enforcement Shukla discusses the song's origin in the novel Anandmath. While the opening verses praise nature, the later verses equate the land with Goddess Durga, which conflicts with the Islamic prohibition of idol worship. He reminds viewers that national leaders like Subhash Chandra Bose and Maulana Azad had already found a middle ground decades ago. Saurabh Shukla: "इस मुद्दे को चर्चा में लाने की वजह क्या है? क्या वंदे मातरम को लेकर कोई विवाद था? वह चाहते हैं कि मुसलमान रिएक्ट करें... और जब-जब मुसलमान धर्म की बात करेगा तो वो मेजॉरिटी को पोलराइज कर लें।" [00:07:46 - 00:11:15] Real Issues vs. Identity Politics Saurabh lists the actual crises—farmers' struggles, IT layoffs, and rising inflation. He argues that identity politics serves as a distraction. He notes that even Deobandi scholars have stated that while they respect the song, forced participation violates democratic rights. [00:11:16 - 00:12:11] The Political Spectrum: Masood and Joshi The video concludes with a series of reactions from different political and religious spectrums. Congress leader Imran Masood emphasizes that constitutional religious freedom must coexist with national respect. Imran Masood: "वंदे मातरम का सम्मान करेंगे, वंदे मातरम राष्ट्रगीत है... लेकिन मुझे अपना धर्म मानने की आजादी संविधान ने दी है। आपकी संवैधानिक आजादी का पालन करेंगे हम।" Representing the supporting view, RSS leader Bhaiyya Ji Joshi argues that the song is purely about love for the country and should have been made mandatory a long time ago. Bhaiyya Ji Joshi: "इसमें हिंदू बनने का कोई सवाल नहीं है। वंदे मातरम... वो देशभक्ति का गीत है। इसमें हिंदू-मुसलमान करने का कोई कारण नहीं और इसलिए यह होना चाहिए था, पहले होना चाहिए था।" Conclusion Saurabh analysis suggests that patriotism is best when it is a voluntary emotion, not a state-mandated performance. By dredging up a 75-year-old settled debate, the political establishment may be looking for electoral gains, but it risks damaging social harmony. #vandemataram #deshbhakti #politics #history #debate #nationalsong #analysis #owaisi #yogiadityanath Join this channel to get access to perks:    / @theredmike.   The Red Mike is a new movement in centrist Journalism. We tell your stories. Ground reports the way they should be. To say what’s right, and not what is just popular. Stories from India & around the world that impact and affect you. Your Mike. Your Story. . For advertisement & Sponsorship Email us at - ads@theredmike.com WhatsApp Number: +91- 9821728111 . . . . रेड माइक पत्रकारिता में एक नया आंदोलन है। हम आपकी कहानियाँ सुनाते हैं। ग्राउंड रिपोर्ट वैसी ही जैसी होनी चाहिए. बात ऐसी जो सही हो, सिर्फ़ लोकप्रिय नहीं। भारत और दुनिया भर से कहानियाँ जो आपको प्रेरित और प्रभावित करती हैं। लाल माइक - आपका माइक, आपकी आवाज़। FOLLOW US ON FACEBOOK : facebook.com/TheRedMike FOLLOW US ON TWITTER : x.com/theredmike FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM : instagram.com/theredmike FOLLOW US ON WHATSAPP : whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaGhJSNCxoB5Wfdedr0Z #TheRedMike #लालमाइक #laalmike