Why Hadith Contradicts the Quran: The Case for Quran-Only Guidance скачать в хорошем качестве

Why Hadith Contradicts the Quran: The Case for Quran-Only Guidance

This lecture examines the complex relationship between the Qur'an and Hadith, asserting that Hadith exists outside the Qur'an's teachings. The speaker argues that the Qur'an is complete and self-sufficient, utilizing verses to challenge the authority of Hadith collections and highlighting discrepancies between Qur'anic principles and Hadith narratives, especially regarding issues like justice and women's status. A historical analysis reveals the significant delay in Hadith compilation raises questions about their reliability. Furthermore, the discussion addresses the political motivations behind Hadith proliferation in the Abbasid period, suggesting that these narratives were often used to legitimize authority rather than reflect authentic teachings of the Prophet Muhammad. The lecture advocates a return to Qur'anic guidance, proposing a focus on direct divine testimony over human-authored Hadith in the understanding of Islamic faith. 0:00 Introduction & Opening Praise 0:15 Purpose: Hadith vs Quran 0:43 Sunnah in the Quran 1:15 Quranic Verses on Hadith 2:44 Quran: Complete & Fully Detailed 3:20 History of Hadith Compilation 5:24 Bukhari's Claims & Impossibility 7:30 Abu Hurairah & Caliphs' Hadith 8:39 Contradictions: Hadith vs Quran 10:28 Scholarly Doubts & Conjecture 11:43 Political Motives for Hadith 16:03 God's Testimony vs Human Testimony 17:53 Quranic Preservation & Literacy 19:24 Problematic Hadith Teachings 20:32 Prayer & Practice Without Hadith 22:24 Obeying the Messenger & Quran 23:25 Quran Needs No Human Explanation 24:21 Messenger of the Covenant & Code 19 25:01 Conclusion: Quran is Sufficient