У нас вы можете посмотреть бесплатно Ep1: Intro to Dan Brubaker's 20 Qur'anic Corrections или скачать в максимальном доступном качестве, видео которое было загружено на ютуб. Для загрузки выберите вариант из формы ниже:
Если кнопки скачивания не
загрузились
НАЖМИТЕ ЗДЕСЬ или обновите страницу
Если возникают проблемы со скачиванием видео, пожалуйста напишите в поддержку по адресу внизу
страницы.
Спасибо за использование сервиса ClipSaver.ru
These are a new set of 8 episodes which were created to help Christians who are working with Muslims, as well as Muslims who desire to deal with some of the problems with their foundations; namely the Qur'an. This particular series concerns the Qur’an, and whether it has been perfectly preserved. Back in 2014 Jay did a debate with Dr Shabir Ally in Toronto where he introduced, by simply holding them up, a number of corrections out of a total of 800 which had been found by Dr Dan Brubaker and included in his doctoral thesis. Because they were not yet published, he could go no further than hold them up. Since that time that debate has been watched by over 500,000, and Muslims have responded by saying that Jay couldn’t be trusted because he doesn’t speak Arabic (though he can read and write it). That is why Al Fadi has joined with Jay in this series, as he is a native Arab from Saudi Arabia, who speaks not only modern standard Arabic, but works in the more archaic Qur’anic Arabic, and is doing his doctoral research in this area of research concerning the earliest Qur’anic manuscripts. Muslims have claimed that these corrections are nothing more than simple dialectical differences, or different readings, popularly known as ‘Ahruf’, or ‘Qira’at’. Al Fadi, in this first episode, quickly dispels this notion, noting that the corrections which we are referring to have nothing to do with dialectical differences, or differences with how someone might read it, or even pronounce it. These differences are consonantal differences, in other words, they are changes to the actual written text, known as ‘Rasm’ in Arabic. More about this will be explained later on in other episodes. Muslims make 4 claims about their Arabic Qur’an: 1) It is un-created, or eternal (Surah 85:22) 2) It was sent down to one man, Muhammad in 22 years 3) It was compiled completely by Uthman in 652 AD 4) It has never changed in the last 1400 years Jay and Al Fadi can’t confront the first two claims, but they can and plan to confront the last two claims, that it was compiled completely in 652 AD, and has never changed since that time. Thus, they are asking 3 simple things of Muslims…to show them one complete manuscript of the Qur’an (114 Surahs), from the time of Uthman (652 AD), which is unchanged (i.e. a manuscript which corresponds exactly with our current 1924 ‘Hafs’ text). What they are asking, and what they are doing is simply known as Textual Criticism, a test which every sacred or historical book has to pass (and the Qur’an, like the Bible is both). This is the same test which the Bible had to undergo back in the 1800s but has since passed with ‘flying colors’. It is now time for the Qur'an to take and pass the same test. No Christian would make the claim about their Bible that Muslims are now making about their Qur’an. We would never suggest that our Bible is eternal, nor uncreated, nor that it was sent down from heaven to one man (inspired by God, yes, but not ‘sent down’). We would, however, claim that the Bible was complete in its original form, and though we admit there have been changes in the Bible since the first century, we would be clear that what we have today, because of the enormous manuscript and textual trove at our disposal today, is pretty much 99.9% the same as that which was written down in its original form in the first century AD. So, join us as we delve into the last two claims by Muslims concerning their Qur’an, and try to ascertain whether the Qur’an can be traced textually back to the time of Muhammad, or even Uthman, and whether the Qur’an Muslims have today is exactly the same as that which we can find in the earliest Qur’anic manuscripts; or whether, indeed, our current Qur’an has been corrected over the intervening 1400 years. Watch these 8 episodes, and then you decide. © Pfander Centre for Apologetics - US, 2019 (24,550)