A Critical Study of The Prevention of Atrocities Act | Dr. Sufiya Pathan | скачать в хорошем качестве

A Critical Study of The Prevention of Atrocities Act | Dr. Sufiya Pathan |

In this eye-opening analysis, Dr. Sufiya Pathan challenges conventional narratives about caste violence in India through rigorous data examination. Drawing from official NCRB statistics, parliamentary reports, and case law, she reveals startling inconsistencies between India's Prevention of Atrocities Act (POA) implementation and the actual patterns of crime against Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Dr. Pathan examines how data is collected, interpreted, and presented to both domestic and international audiences, questioning whether the POA solves existing problems or creates new ones. This research-driven presentation offers a rare critical perspective on how caste-based legislation functions in practice versus theory. ABOUT DR. SUFIYA PATHAN: Dr. Pathan is a researcher at the Centre for Scientific Social Studies, supported by the Sarayu Foundation. Her work on caste systems and related legislation has sparked important conversations about data interpretation and policy effectiveness in India. KEY TOPICS COVERED: The definition of "atrocities" in Indian vs. international contexts Statistical analysis of caste-related crime data across Indian states The five dimensions of the POA Act implementation Critical examination of incentive structures in inter-caste marriage policies Case law contradictions in the application of caste-based legislation Analysis of regional variations in crime reporting and expenditure RESOURCES MENTIONED: National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) data Nihar Sashital's 2022 article on atrocities Parliamentary reports on the POA Act Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment annual reports Supreme Court judgments on caste-related cases https://socialjustice.gov.in/writerea... #CasteInIndia #DataAnalysis #IndianPolitics #POAAct #SocialJustice #IndianLaw #CasteSystem #PolicyAnalysis #DataScience #IndianSociety #CasteSystem #IndianPolitics #FactsNotFiction #PublicPolicy #CriticalThinking Topics Covered: 0:00:00 The Notion of Caste Violence is Impervious to Data: A Cultural Self-Goal 0:01:26 Where the Idea Begins: Understanding the Prevention of Atrocities Act 0:04:27 From Enactment to Amendment: Justice Deferred or Delivered? The POA Act Through Courts and Controversy 0:12:08 Defining Atrocity: Global Standards vs. Insult as Atrocity in Context of the Legal Weight of Caste in India 0:17:19 Compensation and The Misuse: Features of POA, That Infringe Fundamental Rights 0:19:58 Funding Injustice: Expenditure Disparities in POA Act Implementation 0:26:39 Incentivization of Inter-Caste Marriages: Specific to SC/ST 0:34:22 Marriage Without Caste Integration? What Are We Really Incentivising? 0:41:21 Facts That Fracture the Narrative: Is the POA Act Built on Broken Data? 0:50:26 If OBCs Are the Perpetrators, Are We Misreading Caste Violence? 0:54:23 Do SC/STs Face Inordinate Violence? The Data Says Otherwise 1:00:10 Equating Insults with Murders: The Crisis of Proportionality in Caste Law That Reinforces The Caste System 1:05:45 Caste Law and International Standards: The Consequences of The Global Misreading of India’s Caste Data 1:08:45 Laws Without Thought: The Crisis of Uncritical Legislation in India 1:20:48 Criticizing Bhagavan Ram is Free Speech, Criticizing Ambedkar is a Crime? 1:23:02 The Flawed Foundations of Social Law 1:26:20 Crimes Within the Community SC/ST Communities are not Considered as Atrocities 1:29:30 Applying Western Lenses to Indian Faultlines: A Misfit Model 1:40:15 Scientific Study vs. Ideological Indoctrination: Who Controls the Narrative? Join this channel to get access to perks:    / @sangamtalks   Join our YouTube channel to get updated on new video releases: Hindi :    / sangamhindi   English :    / sangamtalks   Tamil :    / @sangamtalkstamiz   Punjabi :    / @sangamtalkspunjabi   Bhojpuri :    / @sangamtalksbhojpuri   Marathi :    / @sangamtalksmarathi   Malayalam :    / @sangamtalksmalayalam   Shorts :    / @sangamtalksclips   Bangla :    / @sangamtalksbangla   For updates you may follow us on: Facebook :   / sangamtalks   Instagram :   / sangamtalks   Telegram : https://t.me/sangamtalks Twitter :   / sangamtalks   Whatsapp: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va95... Linkedin:   / sangamtalks   Website : https://www.sangamtalks.org Donate : https://www.sangamtalks.org/donate