Lt Col Daniel Davis: U.S. General Undermines Trump's Russia Ukraine Peace Talks скачать в хорошем качестве

Lt Col Daniel Davis: U.S. General Undermines Trump's Russia Ukraine Peace Talks

Ukraine is not winning the war and cannot win under the current trajectory. He criticizes optimistic statements by U.S. military officials—particularly General Christopher Cavoli—as detached from reality, and claims that such messages falsely encourage continued Ukrainian resistance rather than seeking a negotiated settlement. Key Points: Ukraine’s Failed Offensive & Russian Dominance (Post-2023): The speaker states Ukraine’s 2023 offensive failed badly, with Ukrainian forces being “crushed” and unable to break Russian defenses. Since then, Russia has maintained a slow, methodical offensive, degrading Ukraine’s military capacity. Western Narratives Are Misleading: European and U.S. leaders continue to promote the narrative of long-term support and Ukrainian resilience. This gives President Zelensky false hope and delays a potentially necessary negotiation. Critique of General Cavoli's Testimony: Cavoli claims Russia’s military is weakening and Ukraine is improving—claims the speaker rejects. Cavoli praises Ukrainian development, F-16 deployments, and long-range missile effectiveness. The speaker sees these as inaccurate or misleading, arguing that any real gains are minor and superficial. Long-Range Weapons Are Overhyped: While some Western missiles hit targets inside Russia, the speaker says they are mere “pinpricks” that don't alter the war’s trajectory. Russian electronic warfare has severely reduced Western missile effectiveness. Attritional Warfare Favors Russia: The war has become one of attrition. Russia has more manpower, industrial capacity, and logistical support. These “inputs” make a Ukrainian victory impossible, according to the speaker. Cavoli's Optimism vs. Reality: Cavoli says there’s "nothing inevitable" in war, and Ukraine is improving. The speaker counters that in wars of attrition, outcomes are often inevitable, and all signs point to eventual Russian victory. Inevitability of Ukrainian Defeat: The speaker concludes Ukraine will eventually collapse—either due to exhaustion or a major Russian offensive. Russia could “walk into Kyiv” unopposed or break through Ukrainian lines with a large, reserve force. Tone and Conclusion: The speaker is deeply skeptical of Western leadership and military assessments, accusing them of promoting propaganda and delaying an inevitable outcome at great human and material cost. He urges realism and a shift toward negotiation before further destruction occurs.