BREAKING: Fifth Circuit DEFIES 9-0 Supreme Court Ruling — Case May Head Back to SCOTUS скачать в хорошем качестве

BREAKING: Fifth Circuit DEFIES 9-0 Supreme Court Ruling — Case May Head Back to SCOTUS

BREAKING: Fifth Circuit DEFIES 9-0 Supreme Court Ruling — Case May Head Back to SCOTUS The Fifth Circuit just issued a ruling that appears to DEFY a UNANIMOUS 9-0 Supreme Court decision from just MONTHS ago! Barnes v Felix could be heading back to the Supreme Court ALREADY because the Fifth Circuit seems to have ignored the Court's instructions! What Happened: ✅ Officer shot fleeing driver during TOLL VIOLATION stop ✅ Fifth Circuit used "moment of threat" rule - upheld officer ✅ Supreme Court UNANIMOUSLY (9-0) reversed ✅ Ordered "totality of circumstances" analysis instead ✅ Fifth Circuit re-ruled WITHOUT new briefs/arguments ✅ Reached SAME conclusion favoring officer! The Problem: 🔥 Fifth Circuit claims to apply new test but reaches same result 🔥 No new briefs or oral arguments requested 🔥 Judge previously said officer would LOSE under new test 🔥 En banc review DENIED quickly 🔥 Looks like judicial defiance of SCOTUS Why This Matters: Tests Supreme Court authority Affects ALL police interactions Started as minor toll violation Officer CREATED danger by jumping on car "Totality of circumstances" only works if honestly applied Could expand police power dramatically ⚠️ DISCLAIMER: This video analyzes legal proceedings. Always comply with lawful police orders. Consult attorney for legal advice. #Barnes #Felix #FifthCircuit #SupremeCourt #ExcessiveForce #JudicialDefiance