Ay. Al-Khabbaz’s Academic Opinion of Sh. Muttahari’s “Ashura Misrepresentations" (Maqtal Tahrif) скачать в хорошем качестве

Ay. Al-Khabbaz’s Academic Opinion of Sh. Muttahari’s “Ashura Misrepresentations" (Maqtal Tahrif)

eSHIA - Ay. Munir Al-Khabbaz is asked his opinion of Shaheed Muttahari's book, al-Malḥama al-Ḥussayniyah, which has been translated in English as "Ashura Misrepresentations and Distortions" (And in urdu as “Tehrifaat-e-Ashura”). He starts by saying that there is a difference in opinion as to whether the book can be attributed to Sh. Muttahari. He then gives examples of doubts the author raised about certain events of Karbala and refutes each of these academically (a worthy watch!). He mentions that there are 63 such mistakes he has found in Shaheed Muttahari's book. And concludes by discussing the difference between a thinker and a researcher. Chapters: 00:00 Intro and Question 00:30 Did Sh. Muttahari write the book? 01:45 Sayyid Jaffer Murtadha Al-Amili's book refuting 01:45 #1: Zainab ('a) present at the body of Hussain ('a)? 03:10 Refute 1: How many Zainabs were there? 04:56 #2a: Return of captives on 20th Saffar - the source 06:02 #2b: Timespan to return from Syria to Karbala not enough 06:35 #2c: Issues with the route they took 07:14 Refute 2a: Source 1 - Syed Ibn Tawus 08:00 Refute 2b: The timespan is enough 09:03 Refute 2c: The route today vs then 09:52 Refute 2a: Source 2 - Sh. Saduq 10:17 Refute 2a: Source 3 & 4 - Al-Biruni & Al-Qazwini 11:04 Refute 2a: Sh. Muttahari error - Ibn Namah 12:06 Book has 63 mistakes 12: 46 Sh. Muttahari status - diff between thinker/ historian Sh. Muttahari's books in 2 Parts: https://www.al-islam.org/al-tawhid/vo... https://www.al-islam.org/al-tawhid/vo... The original video is 25:00 to 40:00 https://www.youtube.com/live/1QbBoYbg... #ashura #muharram #misrepresentation #tareekh #maqtal #ahlulbayt #karbala #imamhusain #hussain #husayn #imam #shia #islamichistory #husayn #ayatullah #history #muharram #yazeed #yazid #muttahari #ayatullah