Nominee बना Owner, Legal Heir रह गया खाली हाथ! Realestate News скачать в хорошем качестве

Nominee बना Owner, Legal Heir रह गया खाली हाथ! Realestate News

क्या Nominee ही Owner बन सकता है? High Court ने साफ़ किया कि Legal Heir को सदस्यता तभी मिलेगी जब Civil Court से Proper Documents हों। जानिए इस अहम Society Judgment का पूरा विश्लेषण CA Ramesh Prabhu से। #NomineeVsLegalHeir #SocietyRules #HousingSocietyLaw #HighCourtJudgment #LegalAwareness #NominationTransfer #SocietyMembership #mahasewanews #realestatenews #maharashtranews PDF Download https://drive.google.com/drive/folder... Fill this form to book your appointment https://client.prabhuassociates.in/fo... Join Our WhatsApp Channel https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VadW... 00:00 - Nominee ज़्यादा महत्वपूर्ण है या Legal Heir? 00:44 - नॉमिनेशन के बाद Society ने क्या किया? 01:24 - क्या Legal Heir सीधे Deputy Registrar से मेंबरशिप ले सकता है? 02:42 - क्या Society Resolution को Registrar overrule कर सकता है? 03:17 - क्या Registrar Legal Heir तय कर सकता है? 03:48 - क्या Nomination सोसाइटी पर binding होता है? 04:22 - कौनसे Court Judgments से Nominee को हक मिला? 04:58 - Legal Heir को सदस्यता पाने के लिए Civil Court क्यों ज़रूरी? 06:13 - नॉमिनी के खिलाफ मेंबरशिप पाने की सही प्रक्रिया क्या है? Case Summary Case Title: Abhijit Ramrao Salunke vs. The Divisional Joint Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Nashik Division & Others Case Number: Writ Petition No. 10614 of 2023 Court: High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Bench at Aurangabad Coram: Justice Kishore C. Sant Date Reserved: 30th September 2024 Date Pronounced: 3rd December 2024 👥 Parties Involved Petitioner: Abhijit Ramrao Salunke (Grandson of deceased member Chhabubai Salunke) Respondent No. 1 & 2: Divisional Joint Registrar & Deputy Registrar of Cooperative Societies Respondent No. 3: Concerned Cooperative Housing Society (Owner of Plot No. 55) Respondent No. 4: Son of deceased Chhabubai (Uncle of the petitioner) ⚖️ Background of the Case Chhabubai Salunke, a member of the respondent cooperative housing society, was allotted Plot No. 55. During her lifetime: On 21.09.2019, she nominated her grandson (the petitioner), which the society accepted through Resolution No. 5. On 26.04.2021, she applied for the transfer of the plot and shares to the petitioner. The society approved this on 03.06.2021 via Resolution No. 4. After her death on 07.02.2022: Respondent No. 4 (her son) applied for membership twice, which was rejected by the society. He then approached the Deputy Registrar, who treated his application as an appeal and ordered that the petitioner’s membership be cancelled and granted to Respondent No. 4. The Divisional Joint Registrar confirmed this order, prompting the writ petition by the petitioner. 🔍 Issues for Consideration Whether the authorities under the Cooperative Societies Act can overrule society resolutions based on valid nomination and membership transfer? Whether nomination under Section 23 of the MCS Act is binding on the society? Whether questions of heirship fall within the jurisdiction of the Registrar? 📜 Findings of the Court The petitioner was validly nominated and admitted as a member based on Chhabubai’s application and subsequent society resolutions. The resolutions passed by the society were not challenged by Respondent No. 4. Section 23 of the Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act permits a member to nominate and transfer shares/membership. Nomination is binding on the society. Disputes about heirship must be resolved in civil court, not by the Registrar. The decisions by the Deputy and Divisional Joint Registrar were held to be without jurisdiction. 📚 Key Case Laws Cited Indrani Wahi v. Registrar of Cooperative Societies (AIR 2016 SC 1969): Held that nominee has binding rights in cooperative society matters. Bajarang Labour Cooperative Society v. Divisional Joint Registrar (2016 (2) Bom CR 328) Harsha Nitin Kokate v. Saraswat Co-op Bank Ltd. (2010 (4) ALL MR 51) 🧾 Final Judgment The writ petition was allowed. The orders of the Deputy and Divisional Joint Registrar were quashed and set aside. Respondent No. 4 was granted liberty to initiate appropriate legal proceedings before a competent court, if so advised. Social Links: https://linktr.ee/mahasewa ______________________________________________ For more details, feel free to contact us, rsprabhu13@gmail.com shreyashp.pacpl@gmail.com for consultation 🌐Official Website https://mahasewa.org ______________________________________________ A2-302, Laram Center, S.V. Road, Opp: Railway Station, Andheri(W), Mumbai- 400 058 ☎️Tel: 022- 42551414/24