Did Replay Get This Call Wrong? Madrigal Thrown Out Stealing Second...On Ball 4 - It's Past v Prior скачать в хорошем качестве

Did Replay Get This Call Wrong? Madrigal Thrown Out Stealing Second...On Ball 4 - It's Past v Prior

Cubs baserunner Nick Madrigal was thrown out trying to steal second. It was ball four, so why did Replay call him out? As Crew Chief Brian O'Nora explained, it's all about past vs prior...but did they get this call wrong? Article: https://www.closecallsports.com/2023/... With one out and Madrigal on first base for Chicago, Giants pitcher Anthony DeSclafani's 3-2 pitch to Cubs batter Seiya Suzuki ran low, ruled ball four by HP Umpire Pat Hoberg as R1 Madrigal, running on the pitch, slid into second base and Giants catcher Patrick Bailey threw to second baseman Thairo Estrada, who applied a tag as R1 Madrigal slid into the base. 2B Umpire Nestor Ceja initially ruled Madrigal out as Estrada kept the tag on him, but changed the call to safe after discussion with the crew regarding whether the runner had actually past second base or not. After Giants manager Gabe Kapler's challenge, Replay overturned Ceja's now-safe call, declaring Madrigal out for, as O'Nora explained, going "past" second base. We talk about the MLB Umpire Manual's definition for being past a base vs prior to it and wonder if Replay Review got this call wrong by overturning the on-field umpires' safe call, the field umps having determined that Madrigal did NOT pass second base. Facebook:   / closecallsports   Twitter:   / closecallsports   Discord:   / discord